The Murder of Dmitry Revutsky: to Investigate, or to Ignore?
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.31318/2522-4190.2020.128.215209Keywords:
murder of Dmytro Revutsky, musicological investigation, Ukrainian musical culture during the German occupationAbstract
The relevance of the article is due to the appeal to the complex and controversial period of the German occupation of 1941–1944, which is one of the most mythologized in Ukrainian historiography. It was distorted by both silencing the truth and imposing half-truths or outright lies. The murder of Dmytro Revutsky is a concrete example of myth-making in the history of musical culture, which the proposed article is intended to refute.
Main objectives of the article is on the basis of multifaceted elaboration of the collected factual material to verify the available versions of the murder of Dmytro Revutsky, determining the most probable of them.
The methodology. In the proposed article — source study — the central place is occupied by scientific criticism of sources, and methodological tools cover analytical, synthetic, logical, retrospective, chronological research methods.
Results and conclusions. Reconstruction of events showed that at first the German authorities classified information about the murder of musicologist Dmitry Revutsky, which gave rise to a wave of rumors that the composer Lev Revutsky was allegedly killed. Later, an official German version appeared about the murderers from the group of the Soviet underground fighter Vladimir Kudryashov (destroyed in 1942), which was later supported by Soviet ideology, but at first Moscow transferred responsibility for the crime to the German invaders. Valentina Kuzyk called this GermanSoviet version incorrect and put forward her own version, which we called “conspiratorial”: the real criminal is not Kudryashov, but a secret agent of the NKVD. V. Kuzyk considers the members of V. Kudryashev’s group to be “intelligent student youth”, a priori incapable of murder. In turn, we were able to establish that these people were typical representatives of the Soviet proletariat and did not differ in highly moral behavior. Having verified the available documentary evidence, we believe that the members of Kudryashov’s group could well have been the killers of Dmitry Revutsky.
References
[W. s.], (1942). Revutsky’s murder [Vbyvstvo Revutsʹkoho]. Lviv news [Lʹvivsʹki visti], February 13 (No. 31), p. 4 [in Ukrainian].
[W. s.], (1942). The commander of the security police of the Kyiv General District reports [Komandyr politsiyi bezpeky Kyyivsʹkoyi Heneralʹnoyi okruhy povidomlyaye]. New Ukrainian word [Nove ukrayinsʹke slovo], July 17 (No. 163), p. 2 [in Ukrainian].
[W. s.], (1941). [Notice of the death and funeral of D. Revutsky] [Povidomlennya pro smertʹ i pokhoron D. Revutsʹkoho], New Ukrainian word [Nove ukrayinsʹke slovo], December 31 (No. 15), p. 4 [in Ukrainian].
[W. s.], (1942). Death of the composer Revutsky [Smertʹ kompozytora Revutsʹkoho]. Lviv news [Lʹvivsʹki visti], February 11 (No. 29), p. 3 [in Ukrainian].
[W. s.], (1942). The tragic death of the composer Revutsky [Trahichna smertʹ kompozytora Revutsʹkoho], Ukrainian Voice (Lutsk) [Ukrayinsʹkyy holos (Lutsʹk)], January 22 (No. 4), p. 2 [in Ukrainian].
Victorov, А. (2019). Gun between legs [Pistolet mezhdu nog] [online]. Available at: https://jewish.ru/ru/people/society/191126/ (accessed 13 May 2020) [in Russian].
Krasovsky, O. (1942). The murder of Dmitry Revutsky [Vbyvstvo Dmytra Revutsʹkoho], Voice [Holos], August 2, (№ 24), p. 2 [in Ukrainian].
Kuzyk, V. (2006). Dmitry Revutsky: Repressed posthumously: Once again about the “myth-making” of Soviet historians [Dmytro Revutsʹkyy: Represovani posmertno: shche raz pro “mifotvorchist” radyansʹkykh istorykiv], Word “Enlightenment” [Slovo “Prosvity”], April 13–19, pp. 10–11 [in Ukrainian].
Nitsenko (1944). Dmytro Revutsky (On the occasion of the 2nd anniversary of his death) [Dmytro Revutsʹkyy (Z nahody 2-ykh rokovyn z dnya smerty)]. To Victory [Do Peremohy], January 14 (No. 2), p. 3 [in Ukrainian].
O. A. (1942). Lev Revutsky. Posthumous mention [Lev Revutsʹkyy. Posmertna zhadka]. Stryi News [Stryysʹki visti], February 15 (No. 12), p. 3 [in Ukrainian].
Pavlovsky, V. (1981). From memories of Dmitry Revutsky [Iz spohadiv pro Dmytra Revutsʹkoho]. Modernity [Suchasnistʹ], No. 3–4, pp. 104–111 [in Ukrainian].
Feat for eternity: The Book of Memory of Ukraine — the city-hero Kyiv [Podvyh na viky: Knyha Pamʹyati Ukrayiny — misto-heroy Kyyiv]. Ed. A. Timchik [etc.], Kyiv: Poshukovovydavnyche ahentstvo “Knyha Pamʹyati Ukrayiny”, 2000, 906 p. [in Ukrainian].
Revutsky, V. (1942). To the editor of the newspaper “New Ukrainian Word” [Do redaktora hazety “Nove Ukrayinsʹke Slovo”]. New Ukrainian word [Nove ukrayinsʹke slovo], August 2 (No. 177), p. 4 [in Ukrainian].
Revutsky, D. (1945). Ukrainian musical folklore [Ukrayinsʹkyy muzychnyy folʹklor]. Voice. Ukrainian news. [Holos. Ukrayinsʹki visti], May 21 (No. 17), p. 2 [in Ukrainian].
Smotrich, Alexander (2015). My neighbor Olena Teliga (autumn 1941 — winter 1942) [Moya susidka Olena Teliha (osinʹ 1941 — zyma 1942)]. Philological Discourse [Filolohichnyy dyskurs]. Khmelnytskyi, vol. 2, pp. 48–49 [in Ukrainian].
Smotrich, Alexander (2015). Short memoirs of the “executive secretary” [Korotki spohady “vidpovidalʹnoho sekretarya”]. Philological Discourse [Filolohichnyy dyskurs], Khmelnytsky, vol. 2, pp. 49–50 [in Ukrainian].
Sheremeta, I. (2018). The Whims of the Fate of Oleksandr Smotrych (Florinsky) or A Little About Ukrainian Music Criticism of the German Occupation [Prymkhy doli Oleksandra Smotrycha (Florynsʹkoho) abo Trokhy pro ukrayinsʹku muzychnu krytyku chasiv nimetsʹkoyi okupatsiyi], Art Studies: Theater. Music. Cinema [Studiyi mystetstvoznavchi: Teatr. Muzyka. Kino], Kiev, No. 3, pp. 73–81 [in Ukrainian].
Shpilevich, V. and Fedotyuk, P. (1982). And dawn will come [I nastanet rassvet]. Kiev: Politizdat Ukrainy, 118 p. [in Russian].
–kо (1942). At Kyiv [U Kyyevi], Ukrainian voice (Lutsk) [Ukrayinsʹkyy holos (Lutsʹk)], January 22 (No. 4), p. 7 [in Ukrainian].
